(A lone voice whispers)
This love, we once experienced in the darkness
Beyond the long reach of the light of judgment
By family, friends, or enemies
Will go through a new phase of rediscovering
Rewriting our tragic love story
In the Universes Grey Books of History
Like a modern-day Fyodor Dostoevsky
For humanity is sometimes incredibly and intensely in love with all forms of suffering
Where love in action is occasionally a brutal and tragic commodity
Whenever and forever described in relation to someone special
Who can make your heart scream
“Just believe in me”
As if in poetry or wishful dreams
For a love of any kind is never low-key
If you believe in something greater, the eyes of others, can never see.........
(C) Copyright John Duffy
This poem, "Disengaged", is a deeply philosophical and melancholic reflection on a profound, unconventional love that survives outside societal boundaries but remains intrinsically tied to human suffering.
Here is a breakdown of the poem's key themes, literary references, and emotional core.
1. Love in the Shadows (The "Disengaged" Bond)
The opening lines establish a love that exists "in the darkness," specifically beyond the light of judgment from family, friends, or enemies.
The word "Disengaged" in the title doesn't mean a lack of feeling; rather, it suggests a love that has detached itself from external social expectations and rules.
It is a private, isolated bond that is now entering a "new phase of rediscovering" and rewriting its own narrative.
2. The Dostoevsky Connection & Human Suffering
The middle of the poem shifts into a striking psychological and philosophical analysis, explicitly invoking Fyodor Dostoevsky, the legendary Russian novelist known for exploring the darkest corners of the human psyche.
"Humanity is sometimes incredibly and intensely in love with all forms of suffering":
This is a direct nod to Dostoevskian philosophy (particularly prominent in Notes from Underground and The Brothers Karamazov).
Dostoevsky argued that humans do not always seek comfort; we often actively pursue suffering, validation through pain, or tragic drama because it makes us feel deeply alive.
"Love in action is occasionally a brutal and tragic commodity":
This echoes a famous line from The Brothers Karamazov: "Love in action is a harsh and dreadful thing compared to love in dreams."
The poem acknowledges that real, intense love is rarely peaceful—it is often demanding, painful, and costly.
3. The Desperate Plea for Faith
The poem peaks emotionally with a vulnerable, raw human cry:
“Just believe in me.”
This line represents the ultimate desire of someone trapped in a tragic romance.
When the outside world offers nothing but judgment, the survival of the relationship depends entirely on mutual, absolute faith.
The poet notes that this plea often feels like it belongs only "in poetry or wishful dreams," highlighting the difficulty of maintaining such a pure belief in the real world.
4. Cosmic Defiance
The concluding lines elevate the romance from a earthly struggle to a spiritual or cosmic one.
"For a love of any kind is never low-key":
True love is inherently grand, loud, and disruptive;
it cannot be minimized or kept casual.
"If you believe in something greater, the eyes of others, can never see":
The poem ends on a note of defiant triumph.
It suggests that the lovers share a transcendent, higher understanding or connection.
Because outsiders lack this spiritual vision, their judgments ("the light of judgment") are ultimately meaningless and blind to the true beauty of the bond.
Salute.